Shopify’s built-in returns or a returns app?
Shopify now lets customers request returns from their account at no extra cost. Returns apps add more, and some charge for every return. This page sets the three side by side, with the date and source of every fact.
- Every fact dated and sourced
- We make Comeback, so we aren’t neutral
We make Comeback, so we aren’t neutral. Every figure on this page comes from Shopify’s Help Center or from each app’s public Shopify App Store listing or pricing page, read on 12 November 2026. “Not stated” means the page doesn’t say it; it doesn’t mean the feature is missing. Prices change, so check the source before you decide. If you find a mistake, write to support@tansolutions.org and we’ll correct it.
Shopify built-in vs Comeback
Swipe the table sideways to see both columns.
| Item | Shopify built-in self-serve returns | Comeback |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | No fee is named on these pages. It’s a setting in your Shopify admin. (S1) | Free plan $0. Starter $19, Growth $49, Pro $99 a month. 14-day free trial on paid plans. |
| Fee per return | None named (S1, S2) | None, on any plan. “We never charge per return, per seat or for overages, and never change your plan automatically.” |
| Where customers ask | In Shopify’s new customer accounts, after signing in. Also in the Shop app if the order email matches their verified Shop account. (S1) | In Shopify’s customer accounts, from their order, after signing in. |
| EU withdrawal form without sign-in | Not stated on these pages. For Managed Markets orders in the EU, “compliant cancellation and return policies are automatically applied”. (S1) | Yes, on every plan, Free included, with no monthly limit. A link in your store; works for guest orders too. |
| Exchanges | “Exchanges can’t be requested in self-serve returns.” When you approve a return, you can add exchange items yourself. (S1, S2) | Customers can request a size or colour swap or a different item on every plan. Swaps are offered first, with nothing pre-selected. |
| Store credit | Not stated on these pages. | Shopify’s own store credit, on every plan. A bonus on store credit from Starter up. |
| Approval | You get a notification, review the request and approve or decline it in your admin. Automatic approval isn’t mentioned on these pages. (S2, S3) | Requests that meet your rules are approved automatically, up to your plan’s number a month: 25 on Free, 100 on Starter, 400 on Growth, 2,000 on Pro. Above that, they wait for your review. Never blocked, never charged. |
| Return rules | Return rules set which items are eligible, how long customers have, and whether return shipping is free or paid. No exchange-specific rules. (S1, S2) | Rules per region group: return windows and final-sale items. 1 group on Free, 4 on Starter, unlimited on Growth and Pro. |
| Markets | Turn it on for specific markets only on the Advanced or Plus plan, with the checkout and accounts editor (early access). Other stores turn it on for all markets. (S1) | Region groups as above, on every Comeback plan. |
| Return labels | When you approve a return, you can create a return label in Shopify (customer and store location in the US or Canada) or upload your own label. (S3) | Comeback doesn’t create return labels. You can upload your own label to the return as a PDF (5 MB at most): Shopify emails your customer a link to print it, and it shows on their return page. Or give customers your return address and shipping instructions. |
| Cancellations | Customers can request to cancel items that haven’t shipped. (S2) | Not part of Comeback. |
When the built-in option is enough
Shopify’s built-in returns
If your customers mostly want a refund, you don’t need them to request exchanges themselves, and you’re happy to review requests yourself, Shopify’s built-in returns cost nothing and may be all you need.
A returns app
A returns app earns its price when you want customers to swap a size, pick a different item or take store credit before they ask for money back, when you want requests that meet your rules approved without you, or when you sell to EU shoppers and want a withdrawal form that works without signing in.
Apps that charge per return
What 100 and 400 returns a month cost
As listed on 12 November 2026:
- At 100 returns a month with automatic approval: Comeback $19 vs $39.59 (Return Prime), $59 (AfterShip), $147 (ReturnGO), on the lowest-priced listed plan for that volume. Loop lists Returns from $340 a month (its listing says up to 1,000 returns a month; its pricing page says up to 1,000 a year).
- At 400 returns a month with automatic approval: Comeback $49 vs $99.99 (Return Prime), $209 (AfterShip), $387 (ReturnGO). Loop lists Returns from $340 a month (its listing says up to 1,000 returns a month; its pricing page says up to 1,000 a year).
With automatic approval, on each app’s lowest-priced listed plan (plus any listed fee per return) that covers that volume. As listed on the Shopify App Store, 12 November 2026.
100 returns a month
Loop: from $340 a month, starting price. Its listing says up to 1,000 returns a month; Loop’s pricing page says up to 1,000 a year.
400 returns a month
| Item | Comeback | Return Prime | AfterShip | ReturnGO | Loop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fee per return above the plan | None | $0.49 or $0.79, by plan | $0.50 or $1, by plan | $1.25 or $0.90, by plan | Not stated |
| Free plan | Yes, 25 auto-approved a month | Yes, 5 requests | Shopper-funded only | Not stated | Checkout+, shopper-funded |
| EU withdrawal button | Every plan, no login needed | Yes (Start, free) | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated |
| Return labels | Upload your own | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
USD before tax, monthly, from the linked listings; “Not stated” means not in the listing text. Return Prime’s $39.59 and $99.99 use the Grow plan’s volume steps on returnprime.com/pricing. Cheaper: Redo lists $0 with no cap stated; Yanet lists 100 returns for $13.99 without automatic approval, and unlimited returns with automatic approval for $29.99 (cheaper than Comeback at 400). CWILL isn’t charted: its listing doesn’t state automatic approval ($51.50 at 100, $186.50 at 400). Comeback’s Free plan handles any volume at $0, with manual review after 25. All ten apps compared list return labels; Comeback doesn’t create them, but you can upload your own. Return Prime’s automatic approval on Grow is from the comparison table on returnprime.com/pricing. All 10 apps compared →
Fees per return above the plan
As listed on 12 November 2026, these apps charge a fee for each return or request above their plan’s number:
Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
| App | Plan | A month | Included | Fee for each extra |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Return Prime | Start | $0 | 5 requests | $0.49 |
| Return Prime | Grow | $19.99 | 60 requests | $0.49 |
| Return Prime | Thrive | $79.99 | 180 requests | $0.79 |
| Return Prime | Scale | $149.99 | 450+ requests | $0.49 |
| AfterShip | Essentials | $19 | 20 returns | $0.50 |
| AfterShip | Premium | $119 | 100 returns | $1 |
| ReturnGO | Premium | $147 | 110 returns | $1.25 |
| ReturnGO | Pro | $297 | 300 returns | $0.90 |
| Yanet | Professional | $9.99 | 80 requests | $0.20 |
| CWILL | Essential | $29 | 50 returns | $0.45 |
| CWILL | Professional | $99 | 200 returns | $0.45 |
| CWILL | Enterprise | $299 | 500 returns | $0.45 |
| Rich Returns | Standard | $19 | 10 returns | $1 |
| Rich Returns | Pro | $39 | 50 returns | $0.75 |
| Rich Returns | Premium | $99 | 100 returns | $0.50 |
| 8returns | Starter | $109 | 100 returns | $0.99 |
| 8returns | Growth | $379 | 500 returns | $0.45 |
| 8returns | Pro | $989 | 2,000 returns | $0.40 |
Comeback charges no fee per request on any plan; Return Prime, AfterShip, ReturnGO, CWILL, Rich Returns, 8returns and Yanet (Professional) list per-return or per-request overage fees.
As listed on 12 November 2026: Redo’s returns plan is $0 with no cap stated. Yanet’s Ultimate plan is $29.99 a month for unlimited requests. Every other app in this table lists return shipping labels; Comeback doesn’t create labels, but you can upload your own. Comeback’s Free plan is $0 at any volume, with requests above 25 a month waiting for your review.
Questions
Do customers need an account to return with Comeback?
Yes. Returns and exchanges start from the order in Shopify’s customer accounts, the same as Shopify’s built-in returns. Only the EU withdrawal form works without signing in.
Can I use Comeback and Shopify’s built-in returns together?
We suggest one way for return requests, so customers see one set of options. If you use Comeback, leave Shopify’s self-serve returns switched off.
Does Comeback make return labels?
No, Comeback doesn’t create or buy labels. You can upload your own label, for example one from your carrier, to the return as a PDF. Shopify then emails your customer a link to print it.
Is the Free plan really free?
Yes. $0 a month, no fee per return. Up to 25 requests a month are approved automatically; the rest wait for your review and are never charged.
Sources
- S1 Shopify Help Center, “Setting up self-serve returns and cancellations”, help.shopify.com/en/manual/fulfillment/managing-orders/returns/self-serve-returns/setup, read 12 November 2026.
- S2 Shopify Help Center, “Self-serve returns and cancellations”, help.shopify.com/en/manual/fulfillment/managing-orders/returns/self-serve-returns, read 12 November 2026.
- S3 Shopify Help Center, “Managing self-serve returns and cancellations”, help.shopify.com/en/manual/fulfillment/managing-orders/returns/self-serve-returns/management, read 12 November 2026.
- Comeback apps.shopify.com/comeback-1 and our pricing page, 12 November 2026.
- Other apps Each app’s Shopify App Store listing and pricing page, read 11-12 November 2026:
- Return Prime: apps.shopify.com/return-prime, returnprime.com/pricing
- AfterShip: apps.shopify.com/returns-center-by-aftership, aftership.com/pricing/returns
- ReturnGO: apps.shopify.com/returngo, returngo.ai/pricing
- Loop: apps.shopify.com/loop-returns, loopreturns.com/pricing
- Redo: apps.shopify.com/redo, getredo.com/pricing
- Yanet: apps.shopify.com/yanet-return-and-exchange
- CWILL: apps.shopify.com/parcel-panel-returns-exchanges
- Rich Returns: apps.shopify.com/rich-returns
- 8returns: apps.shopify.com/8returns
- Synctrack: apps.shopify.com/omega-returns-drive