Short answer: Shopify now has per-market return and cancellation rules, so in principle you can give EU customers one return window and US customers another without an app. As of our check on 12 November 2026, though, Shopify lists the feature as early access, "available only to certain merchants". If you don't see Add rule under Settings → Policies, you don't have it yet. And even with it, per-market rules cover the window, cancellations and final-sale items. They don't let a customer choose an exchange or store credit themselves.
What Shopify's per-market return rules cover
Shopify's help page describes it like this: you set a default policy that applies to every market, then add market-specific policies. "Each policy covers return rules, cancellation rules, and final sale items. When a market-specific policy exists, it applies to customers in that market instead of the default policy" (Shopify Help: Setting up return and cancellation rules, checked 2026-11-12).
Inside each policy you get:
- Return window: 14, 30 or 90 days, unlimited, or a custom number of days. It can start from each item's delivery or from delivery of the last item in the order.
- Return window overrides for specific collections or products, longer or shorter than the default. If an item sits in two overrides, the shortest window wins.
- Return shipping cost: free, a flat fee per return, or the customer buys their own label.
- Restocking fee as a percentage.
- Final sale items: products or collections that can't be returned at all.
- Cancellation rules for unfulfilled items.
The steps: Settings → Policies → Return and cancellation rules → Add rule, pick the markets under Eligibility, adjust the settings, save.
What stays the same across every market
A few things don't split by market, per the same page:
- Turning self-serve returns and cancellations on or off is a store-level setting for all markets, with one exception. If Settings → Customer accounts has an Order actions section, you turn them on in the checkout and accounts editor instead, and on the Advanced and Plus plans you can do it market by market. Shopify marks that path as early access too. If you use it, Shopify says to "make sure that both are turned on for each of your EU markets."
- Return rules apply to all orders including B2B orders, and you "can't apply separate return rules to specific order types".
- Changes apply only to future orders, never to orders already placed.
And from Shopify's self-serve returns setup page, a limit that has nothing to do with markets: "Exchanges can't be requested in self-serve returns and you can't have exchange-specific return rules." We go through that in exchanges instead of refunds on Shopify.
A sensible split for EU and non-EU orders
Shopify's own EU section recommends, for customers in the EU: a return window of at least 14 days counted from Delivery of last item in order, the Extend to account for weekends or holidays option, and cancellations allowed Until item is fulfilled. A common setup is then:
| EU market | US and rest of world | |
|---|---|---|
| Return window | 14 days or more, from delivery of the last item | whatever your policy says, often 30 days |
| Restocking fee | none (not on a withdrawal, see below) | your call |
| Return shipping | as stated in your withdrawal information | your call |
| Final sale items | only what the law itself exempts | your call |
Two EU points the settings screen won't tell you. A restocking fee can't be charged on a withdrawal, and the original delivery cost has to be refunded; we cover both in shipping costs on EU withdrawals. And a final-sale tag doesn't remove the statutory right of withdrawal. Only the exceptions in Article 16 of the Consumer Rights Directive do that, such as goods made to the customer's specifications or sealed hygiene goods that were unsealed.
Shopify's EU section also says, in its own words, that using these tools "doesn't automatically make your store compliant". The self-serve route runs through customer accounts with sign-in, which raises its own question for guest orders; see the EU withdrawal button for guest orders. All five of Shopify's EU settings, in order and with what to check after, are in Shopify's EU withdrawal setup, step by step.
If you don't have per-market rules yet
Until Shopify opens the feature to your store, one rule set applies everywhere. The usual workaround is to set the default to the stricter EU terms (at least 14 days from last delivery, no restocking fee) for everyone, and handle anything more generous by hand. That works, but it means US customers get EU terms, or staff make exceptions one by one.
Where Comeback fits
Comeback, our returns app with rules per region, groups rules by shipping country: EEA, UK, US and rest of world. Each group has its own window, allowed resolutions (size swap, a different item, store credit with an optional bonus, refund), final-sale tags and auto-approval. The Free plan has one editable group, Starter has the four groups, Growth and Pro have unlimited groups. For EEA orders within 14 days of delivery the refund can't be switched off, on every plan, and final-sale tags never block the separate no-login EU withdrawal form. Comeback is on the Shopify App Store, or see how it works and the plans.
Sources checked
- Shopify Help, "Setting up return and cancellation rules" (per-market rules, return window, overrides, EU section), checked 2026-11-12.
- Shopify Help, "Setting up self-serve returns and cancellations" (exchange-specific rules), checked 2026-11-12.
- Directive 2011/83/EU, Article 16, EUR-Lex, checked 2026-10-01.