Comeback / Guides

Serial returners on Shopify: flag them for review, without declining anyone automatically

Flag Shopify customers who return often, or who you tag, so their next request waits for review. You set the count and period. Nothing is auto-declined.

Also available in Deutsch

Short answer: decide what "returns often" means for your store, for example 3 returns in 180 days. When a customer at or above that number asks for another return, hold the request for your review instead of approving it automatically. Do the same for customers you've tagged yourself. Then you decide each case. In Comeback, that's the serial-returner flag and the customer tags that send requests to review, on Starter and above. Below is how each part works and how to set it up.

Decide what counts as "often"

A fixed number of returns in a fixed period is easy to explain and easy to check. In Comeback you set both:

  • The number of returns. The default is 3. You can choose from 2 to 50.
  • The period. The default is 180 days. You can choose from 30 to 365 days.

Comeback counts the Shopify returns on that customer's orders that were created in the period. Open, requested and closed returns all count. When a customer who is already at or above the number asks for another return, that request gets the flag. With the defaults, a customer who already has 3 returns in the last 180 days gets their next request flagged.

Pick numbers that fit what you sell. A store selling shoes in several sizes sees more honest returns than a store selling candles. If the flag catches too many ordinary customers, raise the number or shorten the period.

Tag the customers you want to check

Some customers you already know about. For them, use a customer tag in Shopify admin. The default tag is no-returns. You can list several tags, separated by commas, and upper or lower case doesn't matter. The customer's next request goes to review with the flag "Review tag".

The name no-returns is only a default. Nothing is blocked: the tag sends the request to you, and you decide. Use any tag you like, for example check-returns, if that reads better for your team.

What happens to a flagged request

  1. The request skips auto-approval and lands in Requests, under Needs review.
  2. It shows the flag: "Serial returner" for the count, "Review tag" for a tag. A request can show both.
  3. You open it and choose Approve or Decline, the same as any other request in review.

Comeback never declines a request by itself, for any flag. Your rules only ever approve a request automatically or send it to you.

Your customer isn't told about the flag. They see the same confirmation as any request that waits for review. The words and the steps are the same.

The flag and the tags apply to requests made on Comeback's return page: returns, exchanges and store credit. Declarations sent through the EU withdrawal form are not flagged.

Why review, and not an automatic decline

A high return count doesn't always mean abuse. A customer may have ordered two sizes on purpose, bought gifts, or had a run of bad luck with deliveries. An automatic decline treats all of them the same way. A short look at the order history usually tells you which case you have, and a decision you made yourself is one you can explain to the customer.

Review also keeps your rules simple. You don't need a separate "decline" rule set for flagged customers. You keep your normal rules, and only the flagged requests wait for you.

How to set it up in Comeback

  1. Open Comeback and go to Rules.
  2. Set "Serial-returner flag: returns in the period" and "Period (days)".
  3. In "Customer tags that send requests to review", enter your tags, separated by commas.
  4. Save. The settings apply to each customer's next request.

The flag and the tags are on Starter and above. On Free, the fields are shown but can't be changed. If you move from Starter to Free, the flag and the tags stop sending requests to review. See what each plan includes.

The help article on the serial-returner flag has the same settings in short form, for when you're in the app.

Where Comeback fits

Comeback, our exchange-first returns app for Shopify, offers a swap, store credit or a refund on its return page, in that order. The serial-returner flag and the customer tags sit in front of auto-approval, so the requests you want to see reach you and the rest run on their own. Comeback is on the Shopify App Store. The flag needs Starter or higher (compare the plans).

Related: exchanges instead of refunds on Shopify and different return rules per country on Shopify.