Comeback / Alternatives

Comeback and Return Prime: an alternative for EU Shopify stores

Comeback and Return Prime compared: plans, fees per request, exchanges, the EU withdrawal button and the price at 100 and 400 returns, listed 12 Nov 2026.

Also available in Deutsch

Short answer: Return Prime is a returns app with a free start and a fee for each request above the plan. Its listing names shipment tracking, an EU withdrawal button on the free plan, and return labels, which Comeback doesn't create. Comeback is a flat-priced, exchange-first returns app with an EU withdrawal form that works without a customer login, from $0 a month and with no fee per return. At 100 returns a month with automatic approval, Return Prime comes to $39.59 and Comeback to $19. We make Comeback; every Return Prime figure below comes from its Shopify App Store listing, read on 12 November 2026, unless a line names its pricing page.

Who Return Prime fits

Return Prime's free Start plan includes 5 return requests a month, then $0.49 for each extra request. The listing names variant exchanges, unlimited return reasons, a customer portal in multiple languages, up to 2 carriers and an EU withdrawal button on Start. Grow starts at $19.99 a month for 60 requests, plus $0.49 for each extra one, with a 15-day trial. It adds refunds to store credit, instant exchanges, Shop Now exchanges and 24/7 live support. Higher plans run up to Scale at $149.99 a month for 450+ requests.

The listing also says Return Prime can "generate return labels, track shipments and send status updates automatically", which Comeback doesn't do. That makes Return Prime a natural fit for a store that wants the returns app to handle return shipping, or that has only a handful of returns a month and is happy to pay per request above that.

Where Comeback differs

Comeback is a returns and exchanges app for Shopify. Here is how it differs from Return Prime:

  • No fee per return. Return Prime charges $0.49 or $0.79 for each request above the plan, depending on the plan. Comeback never charges per return: above your plan's number, requests wait for your review at no extra cost.
  • Flat plans. Comeback Free approves 25 requests a month automatically; Starter approves 100 for $19 a month and Growth 400 for $49.
  • Exchange first, in a fixed order. Before a refund, your customer sees a swap for another size or colour of the same item, a different item from a set you choose (every plan), and store credit with an optional bonus (Starter and above). On EEA orders the refund stays available for 14 days after delivery.
  • An EU withdrawal form for guest orders. Both apps list an EU withdrawal feature on their free plan. Comeback's footer link "Withdraw from contract here" ("Vertrag widerrufen" in German) opens a form that needs no customer login, unlimited on every plan. Return Prime's listing doesn't state whether guest buyers can use its button without signing in. See how the form works.

What each costs, as listed on 12 November 2026

Comeback Return Prime
Free plan Free: 25 auto-approved requests a month, more wait for your review Start: 5 requests a month, then $0.49 each
Lowest paid plan Starter, $19 a month, 100 auto-approved requests Grow, from $19.99 a month, 60 requests
Fee per request above the plan None $0.49 on Start, Grow and Scale; $0.79 on the plan between Grow and Scale
100 returns a month, automatic approval $19 $39.59 (Grow $19.99 + 40 × $0.49)
400 returns a month, automatic approval $49 $99.99 (Grow, 450-request step)
EU withdrawal feature Form on every plan, no login Button on Start; guest use not stated on the listing
Store credit Yes, every plan From Grow on the listing; every plan on its pricing page
Store credit that can expire Never, or after 12 to 24 months, set per region (Starter and above) Not stated on the listing (read 18 Nov 2026)
Return shipping labels No Yes (listing description)

Cost basis: the lowest-priced plan (plus any listed fee per request) that covers that volume with automatic approval. Return Prime's pricing page shows automatic approval on its paid plans, and Grow in steps of 60 requests for $19.99, 180 for $49.99 and 450 for $99.99 (returnprime.com/pricing, read on 12 November 2026). Sources: Return Prime on the Shopify App Store, read on 12 November 2026; Comeback's prices are from its Shopify App Store listing, in US dollars a month before tax.

Switching from Return Prime: free help by email

Moving from Return Prime? Send screenshots of your current Return Prime settings to support@tansolutions.org: email us about switching. Include your return window, return reasons, items you don't take back, refund and exchange options, fees, regions, return address and the notice texts your customers see. We go through them by hand. We reply step by step with the matching Comeback setting for each one, and your texts ready to paste. If a setting has no match in Comeback, we tell you.

The help is free on every plan, Free included, and you can write before you install. We never need your password or access to your store admin. Comeback can't import Return Prime's past returns, so keep Return Prime until its open returns are done.

Questions to settle before you choose

  • Do you need the returns app to create return labels? Return Prime's listing says it does; Comeback doesn't.
  • How many requests do you get in your busiest month, and what would $0.49 for each extra one add?
  • Do guest buyers in the EU need to withdraw without signing in?
  • Which languages does your customer portal need?

For the wider field, see our roundup of returns apps for EU Shopify stores and the full price comparison. For other apps, see the alternatives overview. Comeback has a free plan; compare all four Comeback plans. Prices change: check Return Prime's listing before you decide. If a figure here is wrong or out of date, tell us at support@tansolutions.org and we'll correct it.