Why this matters
Comeback's returns portal (returns and exchanges from the return page in your customers' accounts) only works with New Customer Accounts. This isn't our limitation. Shopify's own store credit, Shopify's self-serve returns and the Built for Shopify rules for returns apps (from 1 Dec 2026) all need them too. Legacy customer accounts are deprecated, and new stores can't choose them.
If your store uses legacy accounts, the EU withdrawal form still works. It runs on your storefront and never asks buyers to sign in. The returns portal stays off for buyers until you switch.
How to check which you have
Comeback checks this for you on Home, under Customer accounts. You see one of these messages:
- "New Customer Accounts — exchanges are ready": your store uses New Customer Accounts.
- "You're on legacy customer accounts. Exchanges need New Customer Accounts to turn on.": your store uses legacy accounts. A link takes you to Settings → Customer accounts in Shopify.
- "We haven't read your customer accounts setting from Shopify yet. Re-check to read it now.": click Re-check.
How to switch
- In Shopify admin, go to Settings → Customer accounts.
- If you see a banner at the top of the page, click Upgrade in it. If there's no banner, select New customer accounts and save.
- Back in Comeback, click Re-check on Home. You don't need to reinstall. If you haven't yet, finish the other steps on Home: turn on the returns portal and add the return button and the return page to customer accounts. Buyers can then start returns and exchanges.
You can switch back within 30 days. If your theme has custom account pages, Shopify's upgrade guide shows what to check first. Search for "customer accounts upgrade" in Shopify's Help Center.
What doesn't change
- The switch itself doesn't change your existing customer data. For questions beyond the account type, see Shopify's own documentation or Shopify support.
- The EU withdrawal form keeps working the whole time, on either account type.
- Legacy accounts don't block billing. The plan page notes: "Returns portal requires new customer accounts."
Related
New to Comeback? See how it works, step by step.